Hot Cross Crumb Mac & Cheese is The ultimate luxury macaroni cheese for hot cross bun lovers! Fold pasta into this impossibly creamy cheese sauce and top off with crispy hot cross bun crumbs.
Fans of savoury and sweet combos will find this rich and comforting pasta dinner irresistible.
Spring means the arrival of Easter favourite, hot cross buns in the shops (well, from January actually!). There are few dinners I make on consistent rotation but recently, this has become one dish I crave solidly.
Hot Cross Crumb Mac & Cheese comes from my deep love of Cheddar cheese sandwiched between warm, toasted hot cross buns. It’s a classic sweet and savoury snack combination I couldn’t help but make a meal of.
The fact of the matter is that nothing bulks out a dish better than pasta. Enter Hot Cross Crumb Mac & Cheese. Here, I fold short pasta like fusilli, macaroni, conchiglie (shells), penne or even rigatoni into rich and creamy mature Cheddar sauce.
Golden hot cross bun crumbs with crispy sage leaves top the dish off. I love the contrast of lightly-spiced crumbs and sweet raisins against the deeply savoury cheese. The whole affair is a celebration of textures and flavours.
Hot Cross Crumb Mac & Cheese reminds me a bit of fruity Wensleydale with cranberries and apricots at Christmas. Or cheese and mango chutney sandwiches. It feels 50 shades of wrong but when you eat it, it the flavours just work.
This being said, if sweet and savoury dishes aren’t your cup of tea, it’s best to skip the hot cross crumbs with this recipe. Ultimately, this mac and cheese recipe alone still makes for a delicious stove-top meal.
Although my passion for pasta runs deep, you might find it useful to know that you can easily swap cooked pasta for roasted cauliflower florets. A cheeky riff on cauliflower cheese, so to speak. This would make for a great lower carb option or side dish.
Cheese sauce can curdle slightly if the cheese is added to a hot milk mixture too quickly. There are a few things you can do to eliminate this.
1. Use evaporated milk. I like to use evaporated milk from a tin for my mac and cheese. It’s been heat-treated so is more stable. As a result, it produces a smoother sauce without as much risk of curdling on contact with the cheese. I also love the flavour and creaminess of cheese sauce made with evaporated milk.
2. Remove the sauce from the heat before adding the cheese.
3. Whisk the cheese in quickly and throughly.
Yes! Leave the sauce a little on the runnier side to ensure it reheats well without becoming dry. Add a little more milk or pasta cooking water. Allow the cooked mac and cheese to cool and then pack it into a freezer-safe container. Finally, freeze for up to 3 months.
To reheat, defrost the Mac and Cheese at room temperature, transfer to a pan or oven dish for reheating on the stove-top or in a pre-heated oven. Above all, ensure the mac and cheese is piping hot before serving.
Provided the cheese you use is labelled suitable for vegetarians, yes. Check the packaging if you’re not sure.
This recipe is heavy on the dairy but there are some simple substitutions you can make to make a vegan version. Swap the butter for vegan butter or olive oil. Similarly, use an unsweetened plant milk like oat milk or almond milk for the sauce. Add your favourite melting dairy-free cheese in place of the Cheddar and finally, ensure any hot cross buns you use are vegan.
There’s not enough liquid in your sauce, the sauce has been cooked too long or you’ve added too much flour when making the sauce. It’s important to remember that pasta will absorb moisture the longer it sits. Finally, if you’re making this to eat later, keep the sauce on the runnier side and undercook the pasta slightly so it reheats better later.
My method of choice is to microwave in 1-minute bursts until piping hot but you can also reheat this in the oven or on the stove top. However, you may need to add a small amount of water if it’s looking particularly dry.
Anything short is the short answer. Macaroni, fusilli, shells, penne, rigatoni, for instance. Try to avoid long pasta like spaghetti or tagliatelle or anything too small — they’ll get lost in the creamy sauce.
Follow me on social media to tell me how you liked this recipe + get extra recipes!